
NEWS UPDATES
READ THE FULL STORY HERE
Consumer Advocates slam State Farm/
Oklahoma Insurance Department settlement
Oklahoma Insurance Department Commissioner Glen Mulready announced Friday a settlement deal with State Farm, stemming from a long-overdue market conduct examination that found that the insurance giant had violated the Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Act on at least 22 occasions. The settlement amount of approximately $48 million — including $35 million available for eligible State Farm customers whose claims were wrongly denied — could represent as little as $1,200 in restitution, per customer. Further, the settlement does not require State Farm to confess to having broken the law. “State Farm disputes the Examination Report’s findings and conclusions and denies any violation of law or wrongdoing,” a clause of the settlement reads. $35 Million Divided by 27,764 Mulready had promised the market conduct examination would appear in the first quarter of 2026; the documents filed Nov. 10 reveal that the examination of 35 separate claims was not completed until Sept. 30, and specify that the period under examination stretched from 2019 to 2022, but included events beyond that date as well. The dates correspond with speculation from public adjusters who previously contended that the examination was far longer-lived than Mulready had previously allowed. The deal specifies that only consumers whose claims were completely denied — that is, closed without payment (CWP) — are eligible for potential reimbursement. The settlement deal struck by Oklahoma Insurance Commissioner Glen Mulready comes just weeks before the end of Mulready’s eight-year tenure. As it happens, in petitions filed last year, State Farm revealed that during years overlapping the examination, 2019 to 2024, there were 27,764 CWPs in Oklahoma. In other words, at least 27,764 Oklahomans can apply for a piece of the $35 million that Mulready, as his term in office comes to a close, accepted as settlement for State Farm’s wrongdoing. That’s $1,260 per policyholder. One Case Settled for $3 Million News of the settlement arrives as approximately 1000 privately litigated bad faith roof claim cases against State Farm hurtle toward trials in Oklahoma City, Lawton, and Norman. The current batch of bad faith cases followed State Farm’s settlement of 125 identical cases in 2024. The exact settlement amount of all 125 cases combined went undisclosed, but State Farm’s release of the settlement amount of just one of the 125 cases eventually became part of the public record. The amount was not $1,260. The case settled for $3 million. The terms of the deal announced Friday specified that those who have initiated private litigation against State Farm can seek restitution from the $35 million settlement pool, but only if they halt other legal actions and agree not to sue State Farm in the future. “Eligible insureds who have initiated litigation in connection with an Eligible Claim are permitted to participate in the Claims Review Program, provided that they dismiss their litigated claim(s) with prejudice as a condition of receiving any payment approved by the Claim Administrator,” the settlement reads. Attorney General Gentner Drummond, who tussled with Mulready last fall and has filed RICO charges against State Farm in Cleveland County, did not pull punches in listing the ways in which the settlement failed Oklahoma homeowners on questions of accountability. “While this settlement may look good on the surface, the fine print gives State Farm a way out,” Drummond said, in a statement. “Homeowners must sign away their bad-faith claims, and those who have sued must drop their lawsuits to get paid under this 11th-hour agreement. Even then, the most they can recover is what State Farm owed them in the first place, and any money left goes back to State Farm. On top of that, the agreement bars the Oklahoma Insurance Department from ever seeking further penalties for this conduct and prohibits the next Insurance Commissioner from examining State Farm’s practices for 12 months, all while State Farm admits no wrongdoing. That’s not consumer protection. It’s corporate protection.” Drummond vowed that his office’s Cleveland County lawsuit will continue. Long-time insurance consumer advocate, actuary, and former Texas Insurance Commissioner J. Robert Hunter, who has been monitoring Oklahoma’s ongoing roof claim saga for the past year, took a similarly dim view of both the market conduct examination and the scope of the settlement. “The market conduct exam admits that it was altered after other documents came out in private litigation,” Hunter said. “So it was crafted to look like it was responsive to what’s really going on in Oklahoma.” Hunter also said that the potential amount of restitution available for policyholders would be woefully inadequate even if there were as few as 3,000 or 4,000 policyholders in the pool, instead of 27,764. “I don’t think it’s a great settlement by any stretch of the imagination,” Hunter said. Oklahoma public adjuster Ian Rupert, who has represented policyholders in disputed State Farm cases, noted that the market conduct exam revealed that over a six-year period insurance department engineers had discovered that State Farm roof claim cases failed to pay out on valid claims 37% of the time. “I cannot fathom any good reason why it would take the insurance department more than four years to validate blatantly bad claims handling,” Rupert said, in a statement. “Meanwhile, thousands of insureds were being financially harmed and potentially ruined with major out-of-pocket roof replacements.” Beyond being unimpressed by Friday’s announced settlement, Rupert questioned Mulready’s motivation in announcing the deal nine weeks before the end of his eight-year tenure as commissioner. “Perhaps the commissioner has been protecting insurers at their policyholders’ expense,” Rupert said. “I believe Oklahoma should consider legislation that prohibits revolving doors to industry regulators.” Insurance Commissioner-elect Bob Sullivan, who will take over for Mulready in January, was less hostile to the settlement, but expressed reservations about how the department under his leadership would have viewed the deal. “Looking at the math of it, and the idea that this settlement represents one avenue to find a better claims outcome, I don’t know that we would have accepted it at that dollar amount,” Sullivan said. “This does represent an opportunity for policyholders to get a better look, but nothing about this settlement gives me real satisfaction for the future.” In a press release announcing Friday’s deal, Mulready, a “longtime insurance professional,” encouraged consumers who were potentially eligible to participate in the settlement to not accept the decision of professional insurers. “If your roof claim was closed without payment during this period, don’t assume the decision was the final word,” Mulready said.
Before Weatherford became known as a college town and a center of western Oklahoma it began as little more than an open field. Today the city is home to thousands of residents and Southwestern Oklahoma State University. It also carries a history stretching back more than a century. Its beginnings, however, were far different from the community people recognize today. Weatherford was offi cially incorporated Aug. 3, 1898, with its original townsite occupying a 75-acre cornfi eld owned by John Jones. What was once farmland soon became the foundation for a growing community. The arrival of the railroad helped transform the area almost overnight by bringing new residents, businesses and opportunities to western Oklahoma. The Choctaw, Oklahoma and Gulf Railway reached Weatherford in 1898. Its arrival created an important connection for settlers who previously faced diffi cult journeys to obtain supplies or transport agricultural products. For early residents the railroad represented more than a new way to travel. It provided a connection to other communities and markets while making it easier for businesses to receive merchandise and move products beyond the area. Farmers and ranchers gained access to transportation options which helped support the local agricultural economy. What began as a small settlement quickly developed into a destination for people seeking new opportunities in western Oklahoma. As the population increased the community began taking shape beyond its original townsite. New businesses provided residents with goods and services while the growing population created a greater need for schools, churches and other community institutions. The development of these establishments helped turn Weatherford from a railroad settlement into a community where families could establish permanent roots. Agriculture played a major role in the town’s early economy. Farming and ranching provided much of the area’s economic foundation with corn, cotton and maize among the major crops. The surrounding farmland supplied both local businesses and markets beyond the community. Agriculture also infl uenced the development of other businesses which supported farmers and ranchers throughout the region. As more families settled in the area the demand for goods and services continued growing. Local businesses became important gathering places where residents could shop, conduct business and connect with neighbors. The growth of these establishments helped create a local economy supported by both agricultural production and commercial activity. Manufacturing also contributed to Weatherford’s early development. Operations such as a brick plant, cement plant and broom factory provided additional employment opportunities while helping supply products needed by the community. These businesses represented another step in the city’s economic development as it began expanding beyond its agricultural beginnings. Churches, schools and community organizations also became important parts of everyday life. As Weatherford continued growing these institutions helped provide structure for residents and created places where families could gather. Education became particularly important as the community looked toward its future. One of the most signifi cant developments came in 1901 when the Oklahoma Territorial Legislature authorized the establishment of Southwestern Normal School. Weatherford competed against several other communities for the opportunity to become the school’s home. The decision ultimately favored Weatherford creating a relationship between the city and the institution now known as Southwestern Oklahoma State University. Classes began Sept. 15, 1903, with 113 students and 12 faculty members. The university’s arrival helped establish another important part of Weatherford’s identity. The institution brought students, faculty and employees to the community while creating an educational opportunity for residents throughout western Oklahoma. Its presence also helped connect Weatherford with people from communities across Oklahoma and beyond. Over the following decades the school continued expanding its educational opportunities and facilities. What began as a normal school focused on preparing teachers eventually developed into a university offering a wider range of academic programs. The institution became an important part of the region and helped strengthen Weatherford’s reputation as an educational center. Transportation continued shaping the city’s history as well. Route 66 eventually traveled through Weatherford along Main Street connecting the community to one of the country’s most recognizable highways. The highway became an important travel route for people moving across the country and brought visitors through western Oklahoma. For Weatherford the highway provided another opportunity for local businesses to serve travelers. Gas stations, restaurants and other roadside establishments became part of the experience for people making their way along Route 66. The highway connected the community to a much larger network of towns and cities while adding another chapter to its transportation history. These developments refl ected the changing needs of a community which had continued growing since its founding. Agriculture remained important to the surrounding area while education, transportation and manufacturing provided additional opportunities for residents. Over time Weatherford continued growing beyond the small settlement established at the end of the 19th century. Its original townsite eventually became part of a community with established neighborhoods, businesses, schools and institutions. More than a century after its incorporation the community continues carrying pieces of its early history through its landmarks, institutions and traditions. Southwestern Oklahoma State University remains a major part of the city’s identity while Route 66 and historic buildings serve as reminders of earlier chapters. The city may look considerably different from the settlement established in 1898 but its beginnings remain an important part of the story behind Weatherford. What started as a small townsite surrounded by farmland eventually developed into a community with a lasting place in western Oklahoma.
Meet our Team





Liliana Walker
News Team
Phillip Reid
Publisher
Jack Lederman
News Team
Sports Team
Colombia Castro
Digital Media Director
Joey Ross
News Team
Sports Team


